• The Attic

  • The Filing Cabinet

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 43 other followers

  • Advertisements

A Girl of the Limberlost by Gene Stratton-Porter

childrensclassicsFirst off, let me confess something: I picked up A Girl of the Limberlost thinking I had read it (and loved it) as a child, per the instructions for this month’s Children’s Classics bookclub at 5 Minutes for Books.
However, I was only about a quarter of the way into the book and realized that I was blissfully unfamiliar with the plot.  Oh.  I must’ve only read its prequel, Freckles, at the recommendation of a book-loving cousin and then stopped without learning the extent of Freckles’ influence in the subsequent book, A Girl of the Limberlost.  No matter–I think I enjoyed it every bit as much now as I possibly could’ve enjoyed it as a child. 

(Actually, I don’t think I’d even classify this book as children’s literature, although it is certainly tame enough by today’s standards for the youngest of readers who might be interested, even with its dysfunctional families, romance, and broken engagements.  However, because of the age of the protagonist, Elnora Comstock, and the phase of her life this book is about, I think it’s better described as young adult literature.)

A brief synopsis:  Elnora Comstock, the sixteen year old daughter of a neglectful (and at times, abusive) mother, lives at the edge of Indiana’s Limberlost swamp, where she lives daily in the woods and the surrounding environs, learning the ways of all wild creatures, both flora and fauna.  The story opens with Elnora going to the nearest town, Onabasha, to attend high school for the first time.  Elnora is the stereotypical country girl, laughed at by her peers because of her naivete and her wardrobe.  However, Elnora rises to the occasion through the help and love of her neighbors who have acted as her surrogate parents in the absence of her deceased father and her grief-stricken, half-crazed mother.  What transpires after this is the story of a beautiful, extraordinary girl developing into the woman she was always meant to be.  Along the way, many lives are affected by her maturity, her ability to love, and her love for and understanding of the natural world. Anyone who loves Anne of Green Gables or Little Women or any others of a host of literature written around the turn of the twentieth century will also love this book; it is similar in many ways to its sisters:  an unspoiled country girl, through her hard work, character, and lessons hard won through suffering, wins the hearts of all she meets, even those who determined to hate her.

However, the real star of this story is the Limberlost, thanks to Gene Stratton-Porter’s beautifully descriptive writing.  I can’t help but want to find a place untouched by man (where might that be, I wonder?), buy a plot of land, and raise my children there.   (I know this isn’t possible, and furthermore, might not actaully produce a girl like Elnora Comstock, but a mother can dream, can’t she?)  Phillip Ammon, Elnora’s would-be suitor, sums it up quite well in his speech to Elnora:

I understand what you mean by self-expression.  I know something of what you have to express.  The world never so wanted your message as it does now. It is hungry for the things you know.  I can see easily how your position came to you.  What you have to give is taught in no college, and I am not sure but you would spoil yourself if you tried to run your mind through a set groove with hundreds of others.  I never thought I should say such a thing to anyone, but I do say to you, and I honestly believe it:  give up the college idea.  Your mind does not need that sort of development, it is far past it.  Stick close to your work in the woods.  You are growing infinitely greater on it than the best college student I ever knew, that there is no comparison.

This is a lovely, lovely book.  I’m pretty sure this will make my Best Books of 2009 list.  It has whetted my appetite for more Gene Stratton-Porter because I enjoy both her style and her message so much. 

As a side note, I included two different book covers here because the copy I own of the book resembles the first one, and I wish it resembled the second.  🙂  My five year stint as a public library aide when I was an undergraduate college student netted me lots of good books, and this is one of them.  However, the pages are so brittle, they are literally falling apart.  I think I missed a few important phrases (with writing like this, every word counts to me) because of this, so I’d love to add a newer copy of this book (or even better, an old copy in good condition) to my home library.

One more rabbit trail:  A Girl of the Limberlost cannot help but remind me (and others) of Anna Botsford Comstock’s Handbook of Nature Studydue to the obvious name similarity, but also because of the emphasis on nature and education.  Do any of my fellow bibliophiles know if there is a connection?

The redemptive power of love shines brightly in A Girl of the Limberlost, and for that I give it a Highly, Highly Recommended.

Read more about Gene Stratton-Porter here, and for more Children’s Classics, be sure to visit 5 Minutes for Books!


11 Responses

  1. I have this on my shelf (as well as Freckles) and can’t wait to read both of them one of these days. Thanks for the review … I have had so many people tell me that these are great books, but just haven’t slowed down long enough to open them. 🙂

  2. This goes on my “Books I’m Searching For” list! You make is sound so good.

  3. Wonderful review, Amy. And thanks for the reminder! I read this to my oldest two many years ago, and I need to remember to put this title on the list for my other three kids.

    I haven’t read it in quite a while, but my lingering feelings about this story are so warm and nostalgic. It’s a very special book that is enjoyable on a number of levels.

  4. I have heard many positive and lovely things about this book but I have never read it myself! I really ought to because I speculate I would adore it. Thanks for your review (and the reminder)!

  5. Children/YA is all good. I’m glad that you got an unexpected treat!

    I have heard of a few of Stratton-Porter’s works via the blogosphere but haven’t read anything yet. This review is a great encouragement.

  6. I love the “look” of the book! Old and delicious, I can almost smell the pages 🙂 Ya, I’m creepy that way 🙂 I cant wait to read it now!

  7. Hmmm… another new-to-me title, but it sure sounds like it recaptured your attention! 🙂

  8. Hi, I found you with a Google Alert based on Gene Stratton-Porter. Here’s a link to the Indiana State Historic Site at her Cabin in Wildflower Woods. The gift shop sells most of her books in case someone wants to order one via phone or email. (We’re too small for online sales.) If anyone is near northern Indiana, come visit the historic sites and restoration of the Limberlost Swamp.

  9. Well, speaking as a dad, Girl of the Limberlost sounds more like something for my older girl than me. That’s not why I’m commenting, though. You mention Handbook of Nature Study, though. I paged through the table of contents at Amazon from your link and this looks like it might be terrific. Do you have this or have you read it? Is it as good as the contents make it look? I went online at my area library and I’d be 9th in line to get this if I tried to order it, so it seems to have a reputation, even if it’s 90 years since print!

  10. […] ten with a classic that I was surprised to enjoy so much, ‘though I don’t know why.  A Girl of the Limberlost is one of those books I’ve always known about, and I’m really glad that 2009 is the year […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: