• The Attic

  • The Filing Cabinet

  • Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 43 other followers

  • Advertisements

The Love Letters by Madeleine L’Engle


Synopsis (Warning:  Spoilers!): Madeleine L’Engle’s The Love Letters is the story of Charlotte Clement Napier, wife of Dr. Patrick Napier, who flees her marriage and life in New York to go to Portugal to be with her mother-in-law, Violet, who is a brilliant concert harpsichordist, austere, demanding, and Charlotte’s only remaining “point of reference.”  While in the small Portuguese village of Beja, Charlotte is drawn into the story of Mariana Alcoforado, a seventeenth century nun and future abbess who becomes caught up in a love affair with a French soldier, thereby ruining her family and (almost) losing her vocation.  As the title indicates, Mariana’s love letters to her lover (which were published and were both Mariana’s undoing and what ultimately brings her back to Christ) are an important element in this novel, both thematically and as a plot-driving device.

My Thoughts: I feel like I’m treading in deep water here because I am out of my intellectual comfort zone with L’Engle.  I haven’t read her in a long, long time—think sixth grade required reading of A Wrinkle in Time and maybe some follow-up of the sequels shortly thereafter, ‘though I really don’t remember that.  I was pleased to find that Janet at Across the Page has been reading and blogging about L’Engle this week; Janet and I seem to think alike on a lot of issues, and that is certainly true of this particular author.  Like Janet at Across the Page, I am a life-long Protestant, and Evangelical, at that.  Thus, most of the Catholic terminology and way of thinking in this novel was not easy for me to grasp.  Because of where I live in the Bible Belt, I would have to think long and hard to come up with one practicing Catholic I know.  However, also like Janet at Across the Page, I did find the devotion of the nuns and their struggle with faith familiar and encouraging.  It was also fascinating to me to peek into a convent, albeit it a seventeenth century one, and learn about its daily workings.

The most fascinating part about this book is its structure.  The story moves forward as a series of flashbacks and flash-fowards (?) between Mariana and Charlotte.  There are no chapter divisions in this book.  I’ll admit this bothered me a little; I rely on chapter breaks because I read in snippets of time.  However, L’Engle makes abundant use of ellipses and spaces to give a reader ample place to pause and reflect or take a break.  The ellipses often make connections between Charlotte’s life and Mariana’s.  Obviously, I found Charlotte’s life easier to navigate than Mariana’s, and sometimes the real connection between the two was lost on me.  After finishing the book, I’ve concluded that the connection is that both Charlotte and Mariana are looking for the true meaning of love, and they both (finally!) conclude that the only real love is the type that loves just for the sake of loving, not because the beloved has done anything to deserve it.

This is a book with only a few major characters, but the book is really all about characterization.  L’Engle has a way of getting to the quick of the human problem by driving Charlotte (and Mariana) to finally face themselves:

Be quiet, Charlotte, you’re not the center of the universe.  So what makes you think you have any right to be loved?  What have you got to offer anybody anyhow?  Except love?  Your own undisciplined human love.

Why does the joy of love contain so much sadness?

We’re afraid of the sadness because it grows and spreads and becomes too terrible to be borne.  And because it leads to tenderness.


The moment of tenderness, the undoing, unbearable moment of tenderness.  (209)

It is that moment of tenderness in her marriage, brought about by a tragedy, that she must face.

Dr. Ferreira is my favorite character in this novel.  He is the physician who attends Charlotte in Portugal, and he is also the “intimate” of Violet Clement.  He speaks words of wisdom to her throughout the novel, and it is his words that helped me see the point of the novel and kept this novel from just being about two women wallowing about it in their self-pity and angst:

“I think you’re missing the point,” the doctor said, stretching his big body out to the sun, “the point of your life.  You condemn yourself for your love of people, even your love of Patrick.  You don’t need to justify being Patrick’s wife, being a mother, as your career.  It has been a true passion with you, as it is not to all women, and it is as creative a passion as Violet’s fugues, or your father’s strange and brilliant books.  Or as Patrick’s surgeon’s knife.  Don’t underestimate it.  Don’t underestimate yourself.”  (335)

Later he tells her

“Many things hurt, Charlotte.  You must stop paying so much attention to pain.”  (335)

This is not a happy book, but it is one I’m glad I read.  It reminds me a little bit of A Garden To Keep by Jamie Langston Turner (my review is here) because it deals with painful issues regarding marriage and motherhood.  I read The Love Letters as a part of the Semicolon Book Club.   Sherry offered this book as an option with the theme of Christian novels for February.  (You can read Sherry’s thoughts on The Love Letters here.)   Although this is not a Christian novel in the patent way (it was published by a secular publisher and contains a fair amount of offensive language), its conflicts are resolved in a very Christ-pleasing way, I think.

As Mariana’s confessor tells her,

“Love always has meaning.  But sometimes only God knows what it is.”  (231)

*Quotations are taken from the 1966 edition of the book by Farrar, Straus and Giroux.


7 Responses

  1. I’ve only read A Wrinkle in Time and found that to be a bit beyond me. I just didn’t “get” L’Engle and so I’ve hesitated in picking anything else of hers up. Therefore I found your review (and observations about this book and the author) interesting.

    She seems to be a popular author who gets a lot of raves and so I feel kinda stupid when I say I don’t get her. But I don’t!

  2. Well, I obviously don’t always “get” her either, Carrie. : ) We can be “stupid” together! ; )

  3. What a great review, Amy. It sounds like it took a lot of patience and concentration, but it paid off.

    I put L’Engle in the “authors I love” category, though whether or not I like a given book by her depends a lot on timing, I think… If it happens to be working through subjects I’m thinking about, a book by her always enriches me a ton. If it’s about something I’m not necessarily interested in, I have a much harder time. Not all authors have that effect on me… Not sure why it is.

    Thanks for linking to me, too. It was neat to be reading L’Engle at the same time!

  4. I have wanted to read this book for years but it is out of print. 😦 I just recently rejoined the library, though, so maybe they have it! Thanks for the reminder!

    I have pretty much read all of L’Engle’s books over the years except for this one and a couple others that are hard to track down!

  5. […] (Crossed Wires)48. Kerrie- an interview with Hercule Poirot49. Hope (Return from the River Kwai)50. Amy @ Hope Is the Word (The Love Letters by Madeleine L’Engle)51. Deanna (Deerskin)52. Nicola (The Valentine Cat)53. Nicola (Fool)54. CoversGirl (A Plague on Both […]

  6. I finally finished last night – and wrote my review today:


    For your reader who can’t find the book, she might want to try Half.com. I got a used copy for 75 cents plus shipping.

  7. […] you would enjoy this story of failed promises and redemptive love. Check out the discussion at Amy’s review, Deanna’s thoughts, and Carrie’s […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: